Episode 1 Scores and Team Data

[Macka]

So, suggested values would be:

1. Scot – 5 --> 6
2. Tai – 3 --> 5
3. Jason – 3 --> 4
4. Debbie - 3 --> 4
5. Anna – 3 --> 4
6. Caleb - 5 --> 4
7. Alecia – 1 --> 3
8. Jenny - 1 --> 3
9. Peter - 4 --> 3
10. Neal - 2 --> 3
11. Liz - 2 --> 3
12. Nick – 2 --> 3
13. Aubry - 1 --> 2
14. Cydney - 3 --> 2
15. Joe - 2 --> 1
16. Michele - 1 --> 1
17. Julia – 1 --> 1
18. Darnell - 2 --> 1

[Pharaoh Axeh]

Feb 22, 2016 21:42:53 GMT Macka said:

Okay I'm rescoring now. Here are the confessional timestamps.



Doing Tribal now.

Jason question
Jason question
Alecia talks
Alecia question
Darnell question
Scot talks
Darnell question
Alecia question
Cydney question
Alecia talks
Jason talks
Darnell talks
Darnell question
Darnell question
Jenny question
Jason question
Scot question
---------------------------------
Cydney shows vote
---------------------------------
Alecia 3 votes against -9
Darnell 5 votes against -15
Scot votes right +10
Alecia votes right +10
Jennifer votes right +10

Cydney votes wrong +1
Darnell votes wrong +1
Jason votes wrong +1

-----------------------------------------------------------

So my scores would be:

Tai = 30+16 (46)
Scot = 25+10+10 (45)
Jason = 20+20+1 (41)
Alecia = 20+20+10, -9 (41)
Anna = 20+16 (36)
Neal = 20+16 (36)
Debbie = 20+16 (36)
Jenny = 15+10+10 (35)
Liz = 15+16 (31)
Peter = 15+16 (31)
Aubrey = 15+16 (31)
Caleb = 15+16 (31)
Nick = 15+16 (31)
Cydney = 15+5+5+1 (26)
Joe = 10+16 (26)
Michele = 10+16 (26)
Julia = 5+16 (21)
Darnell = 10+25+1, -15 (21)

This is wrong too.  First of all Jason got asked 4 questions by Jeff from the get go, not two. I also have 3 for Scot, since I'm pretty sure Jeff asked him an additional question the second time he spoke. The rules say that as soon as Jeff makes a statement or asks a question, everyone can make + 5 points again, even if they were already talking.

And the voting scores are also not done right:

Votes for person and vote is tied: +5 points
Votes for person in re-vote and they are voted out: +5 points

So they should all have +5 for tied votes and since everyone voted right on the revote, except Darnell and Alecia who didn't vote, they should all have + 5 for that too.

This is my count:

1. Jason - 60: Confessional x 4, TC Speaks x 6, TC Votes in a tie + 5, TC revotes correctly + 5.
2. Scot - 50: Conf x 5, TC Speaks x 3, TC Votes in a tie + 5, TC revotes correctly + 5.
3. Tai - 46: Conf x 6, Immunity win + 16.
4. Alicia - 41: Conf x 4, TC Speaks x 4, vote shown + 5, TC Votes in a tie + 5, Votes against - 9.
5. Debbie - 36: Conf x 4, immunity win.
5. Caleb - 36: Conf x 3, Immunity win + 16, #hashtag
7. Cydney - 35: Conf x 3, TC speaks x 1, Vote shown + 5, Tie vote + 5, correct revote + 5
8. Peter - 31: Conf x 3, Immunity win + 16
8. Anna - 31: Conf x 3, Immunity win + 16
8. Nick - 31: Conf x 3, Immunity win + 16
8. Elisabeth - 31: Conf x 3, Immunity win + 16
8. Neal - 31: Conf x 3, Immunity win + 16
8. Darnell - 31: Conf x 2, TC speaks x 5, votes in a tie + 5, votes against - 9
8. Aubrey - 31: Conf x 3, Immunity win + 16
15. Jennifer - 30: Conf x 3, TC Speaks x 1, TC votes in tie + 5, revotes correctly + 5
16. Joe - 26: Conf x 2, Immunity win + 16
16. Michelle - 26: Conf x 2, Immunity win + 16
18. Julia - 21: Conf x 1, Immunity win + 16

I mean, we have some discrepancies here and there about what is one confessional and what is two, but that is more of a judgment call, so that isn't really important. Like, I agree with you completely with regards to Tai and Jason having important topic changes in their confessionals, but to me Neal was just an extended confessional paralleling his tribe with the disaster brain tribe from Cagayan, but again, judgment call.   

The scores in the first post are completely absurd, though. It would help if we knew where those numbers came from, because I have no idea.

[TMM]

My team gets worse and worse with every post

[gerbil]

Feb 23, 2016 1:15:17 GMT TMM said:

My team gets worse and worse with every post

Don't worry, you're not alone

[survivorfantasy]

so when are scores gonna be up?

[yope]

i am scared to do any trades because everything seems nonfinal but now i only have like 48 hours to make all of my very important decisions and i am dying

[Macka]

Feb 23, 2016 0:50:19 GMT Pharaoh Axeh said:

This is wrong too.  First of all Jason got asked 4 questions by Jeff from the get go, not two. I also have 3 for Scot, since I'm pretty sure Jeff asked him an additional question the second time he spoke. The rules say that as soon as Jeff makes a statement or asks a question, everyone can make + 5 points again, even if they were already talking.

I'm fairly sure Jenna wouldn't awarded points to Jasons' several one-word responses, but fair point. I can't check on Scot, but didn't he speak twice after the same Probst question? Alecia did this a lot too, having long back and forths after one question, and only the first would be counted.

Feb 23, 2016 0:50:19 GMT Pharaoh Axeh said:

And the voting scores are also not done right:

Votes for person and vote is tied: +5 points
Votes for person in re-vote and they are voted out: +5 points

So they should all have +5 for tied votes and since everyone voted right on the revote, except Darnell and Alecia who didn't vote, they should all have + 5 for that too.

Didn't notice this, my bad!

[TMM]

Did you guys double the pre-intro confessionals?

[Macka]

Feb 23, 2016 10:31:58 GMT TMM said:

Did you guys double the pre-intro confessionals?

Nope. Figured that rule was still removed.

[TMM]

Feb 23, 2016 12:38:14 GMT Macka said:

Feb 23, 2016 10:31:58 GMT TMM said:

Did you guys double the pre-intro confessionals?

Nope. Figured that rule was still removed.

Idk but it's in the rules.

[shmady]

Feb 23, 2016 8:22:59 GMT yope said:

i am scared to do any trades because everything seems nonfinal but now i only have like 48 hours to make all of my very important decisions and i am dying

Calm down, gurl! You're just dehydrated!

[Modesty]

Feb 23, 2016 13:27:15 GMT shmady said:

Feb 23, 2016 8:22:59 GMT yope said:

i am scared to do any trades because everything seems nonfinal but now i only have like 48 hours to make all of my very important decisions and i am dying

Calm down, gurl! You're just dehydrated!

he's panicking.

[RDN]

I will post my scores for episode 1 momentarily.

[Teighteen]

Why isn't this being updated? If you're going to take on the role of hosting this, then host it. Why is there no leaderboard? Why are your scores so horrendously wrong? Why aren't you updating the Meat Market? Thankfully I don't have to trade Darnell, but I feel bad for the people that do because they won't be able to lol. Don't commit to something like this if you aren't gonna see it through.

[Macka]

What's happening with this?